Do students know what good looks like – without being told?

You are here

Imagine a fresh graduate arriving at their new workplace and being given their first task. There is no task brief, no examples to follow, and perhaps no one available to ask for advice. How would the graduate know if their work is good enough? Should they keep going, change direction, check another source, or ask someone for their thoughts?

This is where evaluative judgement matters. Put simply, it is our ability to tell whether work is good enough for a particular situation and use that judgement to decide what to do next. It means becoming an independent judge of quality.

Helping students develop evaluative judgement

The encouraging news is that many educators are probably already creating opportunities for evaluative judgement.

In our recent scoping review, we looked at 38 empirical studies of activities associated with the development of students’ evaluative judgement across higher education1. These included students engaging with criteria and exemplars, peer and self-assessment, feedback activities, structured evaluation tools, and justifying their judgements. Many of these are familiar and longstanding formative practices in higher education. What may be different is how we see their purpose.

What stood out was that these approaches were often combined and sequenced purposefully. For instance, students might first examine sample work by applying criteria, compare their judgements with others, explain their reasoning, and eventually use that understanding to judge their own work. Teachers remained important too, by modelling judgement, introducing standards, facilitating discussion and creating an environment where students could safely test their thinking.

The emphasis, I believe, is not on designing yet another activity to develop students’ evaluative judgement. Rather, it is about looking differently at what we already ask students to do.

- When in learning activities are students actively encouraged to evaluate and reflect on the quality of their work?

- Do they have sufficient opportunities to compare, question, justify, reconsider and act on their judgements?

- And do those experiences gradually prepare them to make such decisions when educators are absent?

If we see students as active judges of quality, we can make existing opportunities for evaluative judgement more visible and purposeful; giving students exposure to evaluative experiences rather than simply asking them to complete tasks.

But how do students make evaluative judgements?

One gap we found is that much existing research has focused on outcomes, such as whether students become more confident, whether their marks aligned with teachers’ marks, or whether the quality of feedback given to their peers improves. Fewer studies have followed students’ judgements themselves as they unfold.

We still have limited understanding of what evaluative judgement looks like from the students’ perspective: what they are comparing their work against, what they pay attention to, what they balance or compromise, and what shapes these decisions. Are these judgements always deliberate evaluations of quality, or do they sometimes sit within more practical and familiar decisions about what works?

That is where my next studies are heading. I am looking closely at students as they make evaluative judgements across different assessment activities to build a clearer picture of what evaluative judgement looks like in practice. This also raises another question: perhaps we should ask not only “How do we develop evaluative judgement?” but also “What kinds of judgement are our assessments already prompting students to make?”

Going back to our fresh graduate, if they have had repeated opportunities to exercise evaluative judgement across learning activities, assessments, and different contexts, we can be more confident that they will know what to do when there is no longer a teacher beside them. Their first attempt may not be exceptional, but they will be better able to recognise what needs improving, seek useful input, adjust their approach, and continue learning while they contribute meaningfully in new settings.

If you would like to know how we can better prepare our fresh graduates, you may want to meet Henry, whose story opens Developing Evaluative Judgement in Higher Education: Assessment for Knowing and Producing Quality Work2 and leads into a practical conversation on how evaluative judgement can be developed through teaching and assessment.

 

References

Image generated by ChatGPT


The HERDSA Connect Blog offers comment and discussion on higher education issues; provides information about relevant publications, programs and research and celebrates the achievements of our HERDSA members.

 

HERDSA Connect links members of the HERDSA community in Australasia and beyond by sharing branch activities, member perspectives and achievements, book reviews, comments on contemporary issues in higher education, and conference reflections.

 

Members are encouraged to respond to articles and engage in ongoing discussion relevant to higher education and aligned to HERDSA’s values and mission. Contact Daniel Andrews Daniel.Andrews@herdsa.org.au to propose a blog post for the HERDSA Connect blog.

 

HERDSA members can login to comment and subscribe.